Coffee Reviews: Every Bag We've Tasted and Rated
First-hand coffee reviews of beans from small roasters. Each one gets a score out of 10 and links straight to the coffee's page.
Every coffee we've reviewed
9.0/10Black Oak Coffee RoastersBear Harbor Organic Espresso
We pulled Bear Harbor as espresso, and it makes a really tasty shot. It's definitely a dark coffee, and the flavor leans fruity with a candied nut sweetness.
Read the full reviewRated 9.0 out of 10 · Tasted November 2026
10/10Black Oak Coffee RoastersEthiopia Banko Natural
We don't usually reach for light roasts, but this is the best light roast coffee we've ever tried. Black Oak's Ethiopia Banko Natural is a single origin coffee from Ethiopia with a lighter body. Its sweetness comes straight from the bean and the way it's grown, with no flavoring added.
Read the full reviewRated 10 out of 10 · Tasted November 2026
How we review coffee
We brew each coffee and write down what we actually smell and taste. Then we give it one score out of 10.
The score is our own take, so it can differ from the roaster's description. Black Oak calls Bear Harbor a medium-dark roast, for example, and to us it drinks definitely dark. When that happens, the review says so.
Each review lives on the coffee's own page in an "Our review" section, right next to the roaster's details, brewing recipes and the link to buy it.
Where the tasting notes come from
The product details on each coffee page come from the roaster's own listing: roast level, origin, process and the roaster's tasting notes. The "Our review" section is the only first-hand part, and it's always labeled "Tasted by us."
We list far more coffees than we've tasted, so most coffee pages don't have a review yet. We add new coffee reviews as we taste them, and this page updates on its own.
Coffee review FAQs
How do your coffee ratings work?
Each coffee gets one score out of 10 for how it tasted to us. The review explains the score with what we tasted and who we think will like it.
Why doesn't every coffee have a review?
Because we only review coffees we've tasted ourselves. Coffee pages without an "Our review" section use the roaster's own details and tasting notes.
Can roasters send a coffee for review?
Yes. Roasters can use our request a review form. We only publish a review after we've tasted the coffee.
Do you earn money from the coffees you review?
Some buy links are affiliate links, so we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Our affiliate disclosure explains how it works.
