What Does Medium Roast Coffee Mean? Taste, Color and Brewing
What medium roast means on a coffee bag, how it tastes next to light and dark roasts, and how to brew and choose one. About a 7-minute read.
Medium roast coffee is roasted past first crack and stopped before second crack, leaving medium brown beans with no oil on the surface. It tastes balanced, with milk chocolate, caramel and nutty notes plus some of the bean's original fruit. Acidity is softer than in a light roast and bitterness is lower than in a dark roast. Caffeine is about the same as other roast levels.
"Medium roast" is the most common label in the coffee aisle, and also one of the vaguest. It sounds like a safe middle choice, but it leaves out how the coffee will taste. Here is what the term really means, how medium roasts differ from light and dark, and how to pick one you will enjoy.
Roast level is one of the biggest influences on flavor, along with origin and processing. Our lesson on origin, processing and roast covers all three. This lesson zooms in on the middle of the roast range, where many everyday coffees live.
One caution before we start. Roast names are not standardized. In our own catalog, 35% of listings don't publish a roast level at all, so the label is a starting point rather than a promise.
What does medium roast mean?
Medium roast means the roaster stopped heating the beans after first crack but before second crack. The beans turn medium brown, with a dry surface and no visible oil. That timing keeps some of the coffee's original fruit and acidity while adding caramel, chocolate and nutty flavors from the roast.
During roasting, beans go through two audible stages. First crack is a popping sound as moisture turns to steam and the bean expands. Sprudge puts it at a bean temperature of around 380°F (about 193°C), while Perfect Daily Grind cites about 401°F (205°C). The exact point depends on the beans and the roaster. Second crack, a sharper snap, comes later, at around 446°F (230°C) according to Perfect Daily Grind.
Higher Grounds Trading Co., a roaster in our catalog, describes its medium roasts as coffee taken just past first crack and cooled before second crack, a window of about 15 to 30 seconds in its roaster. Light roasts stop near the end of first crack. Dark roasts go to the edge of second crack or into it.
The National Coffee Association describes medium roast coffee as "medium brown in color with a stronger flavor and a non-oily surface." That non-oily surface is a useful clue. If you see shiny beans, you are looking at something darker.
How does a medium roast differ from light and dark?
A medium roast sits between light and dark on every major trait. It has less acidity and more body than a light roast, and more sweetness and origin character than a dark roast. Light roasts taste most like the farm and process, dark roasts taste most like the roast, and medium roasts balance the two.
| Light roast | Medium roast | Dark roast | |
|---|---|---|---|
| When the roast ends | Around the end of first crack | After first crack, before second crack | Near, into or past second crack |
| Bean color and surface | Light brown, matte | Medium brown, no oil on the surface | Very dark to black, often oily |
| Acidity | Highest | Moderate, often described as sweeter | Lowest |
| Body | Lighter | Medium, rounder | Fuller, heavier |
| Typical tasting notes | Fruit, florals, citrus, tea | Chocolate, caramel, nuts, soft fruit | Dark chocolate, smoke, roast, spice |
| What you taste most | The origin and process | A mix of origin and roast | The roast |
Color, oil and acidity descriptions from the National Coffee Association; crack timing from Higher Grounds Trading Co. and Perfect Daily Grind.
Our catalog data shows how roast shifts flavor. Of the light roasts we track, 96% list fruit notes. Of the dark roasts, only 42% do. The medium roasts in the next section show the middle ground: chocolate and caramel, with some fruit left in. You can see more patterns like this in our coffee-by-the-numbers lesson.
What does medium roast coffee taste like?
Medium roast coffee usually tastes sweet, round and balanced, with notes of milk chocolate, caramel, toffee or nuts. Many also keep a gentle fruit note, like orange, apple or stone fruit. The acidity is softer than in a light roast, and bitterness is lower than in a dark roast, which is why medium roasts are easy to drink every day.
Roaster notes for medium roasts in our catalog show that pattern well:
- Highwire Coffee Roasters Carrier Wave, a washed coffee from El Salvador, lists milk chocolate, caramel and stone fruit.
- Partners Coffee Brooklyn Blend lists creamy cocoa, toffee and dried fruit.
- Larry's Coffee Larry's House Blend lists milk chocolate, orange and cashew.
- Peace Coffee Birchwood Breakfast Blend lists bittersweet chocolate, honey and cedar.
Origin still matters at a medium roast. A medium-roasted Ethiopian like Café Grumpy Ethiopia Yirgacheffe lists malted milk chocolate, apricot and Earl Grey, which is fruitier than a Central American blend at the same roast. A medium-roasted Honduran like Spirit Origin Coffee Honduras Monte Fresco Parainema lists peach, honey and raspberry. Medium roast sets the frame, and the beans fill it in.
What do City, Full City and breakfast roast mean on a bag?
City, Full City and breakfast roast are traditional names for points along the roast range. Breakfast roasts are medium, City+ is a step past a City roast, and Full City is a medium-dark roast that nearly reaches second crack. Roasters use these names loosely, so read the tasting notes and color too.
| Name on the bag | Where it usually sits | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| City+ | Just past City | Slightly more developed than a City roast |
| Breakfast roast or blend | Medium | A medium roast; After Dinner is the darker of the two |
| Full City | Medium-dark | Roasted until almost reaching second crack |
| Vienna | Medium-dark | Roasted to the middle of second crack |
| French or Italian | Dark | Well past second crack |
Definitions from Perfect Daily Grind, which notes there is little naming standardization between roasters.
Medium-dark roasts are worth a note. They sit closer to second crack, so they lose more brightness and gain more body and bittersweet flavor. Higher Grounds Trading Co. Highland Humanity is a medium-dark blend from Peru and Mexico, and the roaster lists caramel and cocoa with a balanced cup. If a regular medium roast tastes a little thin to you, medium-dark is the next step.
Does medium roast have more caffeine?
Medium roast has about the same caffeine as light and dark roasts. Caffeine holds up well during roasting, and differences between roast levels are small next to how much coffee you use and how you brew it. Measuring by scoop or by weight changes the comparison a little, which our caffeine lesson explains.
We cover the details in our lesson on whether dark roast has more caffeine. The short version: if you want more or less caffeine, change your dose or switch to decaf. Changing roast level makes only a small difference.
How should you brew a medium roast?
Medium roasts are the most forgiving coffees to brew. They work in a drip machine, pour over, French press, AeroPress and espresso machine. Start with a standard recipe, about 55 grams of coffee per liter of water, and adjust grind or dose to taste. Their balance makes them hard to get badly wrong.
- For drip or pour over, use a medium grind and water between 195°F and 205°F (about 90°C to 96°C).
- For a French press, use a coarse grind and steep for about 4 minutes.
- For espresso, medium roasts give sweeter, more balanced shots than most light roasts and are easier to dial in.
- For milk drinks, a medium or medium-dark roast holds its chocolate notes through the milk.
If your medium roast tastes sour or thin, grind a little finer. If it tastes bitter or harsh, grind a little coarser.
How do you choose a medium roast you will like?
Choose a medium roast by reading the tasting notes and origin, since roast level alone tells only part of the story. If you like chocolate and nuts, pick a Latin American blend. If you want a bit of fruit, look for an Ethiopian or Honduran medium roast. A listed roast date and origin signal a careful roaster.
A simple way to find your taste is to buy two medium roasts from different origins, such as the Partners Brooklyn Blend and the Café Grumpy Yirgacheffe, and brew them the same way. You will learn quickly whether you lean toward chocolate or fruit. You can then filter by roast and origin on our explore coffees page.
Frequently asked questions
What does medium roast coffee taste like?
Medium roast coffee usually tastes sweet and balanced, with milk chocolate, caramel, toffee or nutty notes and a soft fruit note. It has less acidity than a light roast and less bitterness than a dark roast.
Is medium roast stronger than light roast?
Medium roast tastes fuller and roastier than light roast, so many people call it stronger. Caffeine is about the same. Brew strength comes from how much coffee you use per cup.
Is breakfast blend a medium roast?
Usually, yes. Breakfast blends and breakfast roasts are traditionally medium roasts, built to be smooth and easy to drink in the morning. Check the bag, since roasters use the name loosely.
What is the difference between medium and medium-dark roast?
Medium-dark roasts go further toward second crack. They have more body, less acidity and more bittersweet, roasty flavor. Full City is a common name for a medium-dark roast.
Is medium roast good for espresso?
Yes. Medium roasts make sweet, balanced espresso and are easier to dial in than light roasts. They also hold up well in lattes and cappuccinos.
Sources: National Coffee Association, Coffee Roasts Guide · Sprudge, What Is First Crack? · Perfect Daily Grind, Light, Cinnamon, City: What Do Coffee Roast Names Really Mean? (2020) · Higher Grounds Trading Co., Learn: Roasting Coffee · National Coffee Association, How to Make French Press Coffee · Sprudge, Does Dark Roast Coffee Really Have More Caffeine? (2019) · Seattle Coffee Gear, Achieving the Gold Cup Standard
